Research

Machine Relations Index Report, November 16, 2026: ChatGPT cites editorial publications 2.5 times as often as Google AI Overviews

In the November 16, 2026 Machine Relations Index release, ChatGPT cites editorial publications 2.5 times as often as Google AI Overviews. That is the largest gap in classified source-class share between two engines in this release. reddit.com has the highest citation rate of the 37,905 cited source domains. The edition lists the ten most-cited sources and editorial publications, the largest week-over-week movers among graded domains and the leader of every published segment.

Published Machine Relations Research
Index Analysis
TopicsMachine Relations IndexIndex Report

ChatGPT cites editorial publications 2.5 times as often as Google AI Overviews: 39.9% of classified citations (4,276 of 10,723) against 16.1% (505 of 3,139), as of November 16, 2026.

In the November 16, 2026 release of the Machine Relations Index, reddit.com was cited in 6.75% of observed AI answer runs, 2,712 of 40,194: the highest citation rate of the 37,905 source domains the Index has seen cited, at confidence tier A. In the November 9, 2026 Machine Relations Index release, a week earlier, its rate was 7.05%, 2,668 of 37,851 runs. Across the 184-day window it was cited by Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity, and not by ChatGPT or Claude.

In Cybersecurity / Best tools, as of November 16, 2026, huntress.com was cited in 42.54% of observed answer runs, 114 of 268: the highest leader rate of the 151 published segments. Machine Relations Index, Jaxon Parrott — machinerelations.ai.

This is the weekly Machine Relations Index Report, built by code from the Index's daily public release and compared with the release of November 9, 2026. Every figure links to the Index page that publishes it. The previous edition is Machine Relations Index Report, November 9, 2026: mattressnerd.com replaces youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication) as the most-cited graded source in Physical Consumer Products / Comparisons, at 23.81%.

The release at a glance #

Measure Release 2026-11-09 Release 2026-11-16 Change
Observation window 177 days 184 days +7 days
Observed answer runs 37,851 40,194 +2,343
Citation events 256,949 269,647 +12,698
Cited source domains 36,722 37,905 +1,183
Eligible questions in the basket 1,255 1,255 unchanged
Published segments 151 of 151 151 of 151 unchanged
Segments still collecting 0 0 unchanged
Graded domains, tiers A / B / C 29 / 146 / 1004 32 / 165 / 1043 +61

A segment is one subject category paired with one question shape. It publishes once it has 10 observed runs across 7 distinct run dates. A citation rate is the share of observed answer runs in which at least one engine cited the domain.

The ten most-cited sources #

Rank Source Source role Citation rate Runs cited Tier Engines citing Rank a week earlier
1 reddit.com Community and social platform 6.75% 2,712 of 40,194 A 4 of 6 1
2 youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication) Search or media platform 5.78% 2,322 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 2
3 linkedin.com Community and social platform 4.38% 1,761 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 3
4 forbes.com Editorial publication 3.26% 1,312 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 4
5 techradar.com Editorial publication 2.78% 1,118 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 6
6 medium.com Community and social platform 2.72% 1,092 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 5
7 arxiv.org Academic and government source 2.45% 983 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 7
8 g2.com Market and company database 2.09% 842 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 8
9 yahoo.com Editorial publication 1.86% 746 of 40,194 A 5 of 6 10
10 nih.gov Academic and government source 1.85% 745 of 40,194 A 6 of 6 9

Rates are measured over all 40,194 observed runs, so they read lower than any single segment's rate. "Engines citing" counts the engines observed citing the domain at least once in the window. Each engine's own ranking of sources, from the current release, is at machinerelations.ai/index/engines.

The ten most-cited editorial publications #

Rank among 1,504 classified editorial publications Publication Citation rate Runs cited Tier Engines citing
1 forbes.com 3.26% 1,312 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
2 techradar.com 2.78% 1,118 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
3 yahoo.com 1.86% 746 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
4 healthline.com 1.54% 620 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
5 nerdwallet.com 1.38% 554 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
6 techtarget.com 1.10% 444 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
7 nytimes.com 1.04% 417 of 40,194 B Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
8 tomsguide.com 0.87% 351 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
9 cnbc.com 0.86% 347 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity
10 peoplemanagingpeople.com 0.76% 306 of 40,194 A ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity

Engine coverage #

Engine Latest-successful model Status Days answered Runs returned Runs with a citation Runs returned a week earlier
ChatGPT gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14 healthy 180 9,591 8,592 8,956
Claude claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 healthy 182 9,541 7,612 8,995
Gemini gemini-3.8-flash degraded 157 8,233 2,340 7,841
Google AI Mode not disclosed healthy 141 2,453 1,907 2,363
Google AI Overviews not disclosed healthy 124 1,652 1,117 1,599
Perplexity sonar healthy 184 9,712 9,711 9,075

Engine counts come from the release manifest at machinerelations.ai/data/mri-release-manifest.json. The model column is the latest-successful model recorded in this edition's release, not the model behind every historical run. An engine that answers on fewer days contributes fewer runs to every rate above.

Models across the window. Whole-window engine figures pool the models used during that window. The resolved model is latest-success metadata, not attribution for every historical run. Model periods in the release manifest and engine responses count successful, public-eligible returned runs before engine-day denominator exclusions, not category-specific runs or citation counts. A null model means not recorded; missing or null periods mean historical attribution is unavailable. First and last dates do not imply uninterrupted use. A model change alone is not a collection regime.

Citation coverage and collection. Roster status includes citation yield. Degraded or quiet does not alone prove failed collection: responses can return without citations.

ChatGPT runs. They go through OpenAI's API with web search switched on. The model can change during the window; the release's model periods preserve that history, including runs whose model was not recorded. That is the retrieval layer apps and research agents built on OpenAI's API use. The signed-in ChatGPT app answers with its own models and search pipeline and cites differently: a preprint submitted on 2026-10-11 and not yet peer reviewed found that Google Search and OpenAI's API on comparable models together recovered about half of the hostnames ChatGPT Web cited (48.7 and 50.3 percent on two model settings) and 26 to 28 percent of its exact URLs (arXiv 2610.15382v1). Claude, Gemini and Perplexity runs are likewise API runs with web search; their historical models are recorded in the release's model periods when known.

Method note, 2026-09-25. From that date, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews runs come through a different collection path than earlier runs, with no overlapping days. Google AI Overviews answers collected on the two paths differ in how many distinct domains each cites, so its per-answer figures are read within one side of 2026-09-25, not as a trend across it. Google AI Mode changed earlier: its answers began citing far fewer distinct domains between 2026-08-10 and 2026-08-30, on the earlier path, and a same-hour comparison of the two paths on 2026-11-05 found both citing few distinct domains per answer. Google AI Mode figures from 2026-08-31 on are one collection regime, reported on their own, and are not compared or trended across the August change.

Largest week-over-week movers among graded domains #

Of the 1,178 domains graded A, B or C in both releases, these rates moved most. Change is the difference between the two published cumulative rates, in percentage points. It records that a rate moved, not why: in the same week the basket went from 1,255 to 1,255 eligible questions and observed runs from 37,851 to 40,194, so a moved rate can reflect what was asked as much as how engines cite.

Rates that rose #

Source Tier now (a week earlier) Rate now Rate a week earlier Change
hubspot.com A (A) 1.35% 1.29% +0.06 pts
rankite.com C (C) 0.15% 0.10% +0.05 pts
cdp.com B (B) 0.62% 0.58% +0.04 pts
goodhousekeeping.com B (B) 0.61% 0.57% +0.04 pts
nerdwallet.com A (A) 1.38% 1.34% +0.04 pts

Rates that fell #

Source Tier now (a week earlier) Rate now Rate a week earlier Change
reddit.com A (A) 6.75% 7.05% -0.30 pts
youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication) A (A) 5.78% 5.99% -0.21 pts
linkedin.com A (A) 4.38% 4.54% -0.16 pts
medium.com A (A) 2.72% 2.82% -0.10 pts
gartner.com A (A) 1.41% 1.49% -0.08 pts

Segment leaders that changed #

Category Question shape Leader a week earlier Leader now Rate now
AI Security & Privacy Problem-first research techradar.com, 12.27% arxiv.org and techradar.com (tied) 11.44%
AI Visibility & GEO Best tools otterly.ai and seranking.com (tied), 22.54% otterly.ai 23.00%
Consumer Products Top lists dogfoodadvisor.com, 18.63% forbes.com 18.67%
Cybersecurity Top lists hoxhunt.com, 22.76% expertinsights.com 22.51%
Education & Training Best tools prepscholar.com and reddit.com (tied), 16.04% prepscholar.com 15.82%
Education & Training Is it worth it elearningindustry.com, 14.86% elearningindustry.com and theworkademy.com (tied) 14.03%
Healthcare Services How buyers choose phreesia.com, 12.33% elevatepfs.com and phreesia.com (tied) 12.45%
Industrial Problem-first research oxmaint.com, 11.41% fabrico.io 14.49%
Local Services Best tools angi.com, 19.55% seattlesimplyclean.com 19.31%
Local Services How buyers choose serviceagent.ai and thumbtack.com (tied), 12.92% thumbtack.com 12.94%
Local Services Is it worth it americashousekeeping.com and care.com (tied), 16.76% thumbtack.com 15.35%
Logistics & Freight Best tools softwareadvice.com and wearewarp.com (tied), 14.29% mycarrier.io 14.84%
Logistics & Freight Is it worth it shipperguide.com, 19.50% wearewarp.com 18.78%
Professional Services Top lists peoplemanagingpeople.com, 17.12% kore1.com and peoplemanagingpeople.com (tied) 15.71%

A leader is the graded domain outside the publisher's related parties with the highest citation rate in the segment, on the segment's own denominator; domains tied on rate are listed together.

Segments that crossed the evidence floor #

No segment crossed the evidence floor this week.

Segment leaders by category #

The leader of every published segment, with its citation rate on that segment's runs. "Collecting" segments have not yet cleared the evidence floor of 10 runs across 7 run dates and carry no leader.

Category Best tools How buyers choose Is it worth it Problem-first research Top lists Comparisons News-driven citations
AI Infrastructure medium.com, 26.33% arxiv.org, 21.33% atlan.com / medium.com, 14.43% arxiv.org, 12.37% spheron.network, 28.62% databricks.com, 21.84% Not measured
AI Security & Privacy arxiv.org, 34.27% teramind.co, 18.35% ovaledge.com, 17.41% arxiv.org / techradar.com, 11.44% arxiv.org, 27.30% arxiv.org, 38.14% Not measured
AI Visibility & GEO otterly.ai, 23.00% youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication), 10.90% hubspot.com, 17.26% youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication), 14.50% tryprofound.com, 20.00% hubspot.com, 25.68% Not measured
Consumer Finance nerdwallet.com, 31.79% bankrate.com, 23.42% reddit.com, 17.67% experian.com, 24.29% nerdwallet.com, 36.16% acorns.com, 28.79% Not measured
Consumer Health healthline.com, 41.07% nih.gov, 18.98% uclahealth.org, 29.52% clevelandclinic.org, 31.12% thefeed.com, 22.59% healthline.com, 23.65% Not measured
Consumer Products forbes.com, 30.18% livetinted.com, 18.31% alibaba.com, 17.78% dialavet.com, 13.35% forbes.com, 18.67% petmd.com, 23.44% Not measured
Cybersecurity huntress.com, 42.54% microsoft.com, 17.45% paloaltonetworks.com, 22.53% github.com, 18.06% expertinsights.com, 22.51% vectra.ai, 24.42% paloaltonetworks.com, 13.52%
Deep Tech & Hardware arxiv.org, 20.27% anysilicon.com, 35.37% vlsishuttle.com, 28.87% analog.com, 17.36% unmannedsystemstechnology.com, 26.69% nvidia.com, 17.06% Not measured
Education & Training prepscholar.com, 15.82% coggno.com, 17.61% elearningindustry.com / theworkademy.com, 14.03% indeed.com, 11.89% d2l.com, 12.69% uopeople.edu, 25.97% Not measured
Emergent Prosumer techradar.com, 22.83% atomm.com, 16.21% plaud.ai, 19.77% reddit.com, 14.56% techradar.com, 16.08% youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication), 28.17% Not measured
Enterprise Software erpresearch.com, 39.00% erpresearch.com, 25.97% erpresearch.com, 35.55% cloudeagle.ai / linkedin.com / manageengine.com / zapier.com, 7.28% procuredesk.com / procurify.com, 15.38% erpfocus.com, 15.12% linkedin.com, 11.54%
Family Software techradar.com, 37.07% apple.com, 16.87% impulsec.com, 20.16% healthychildren.org, 18.42% apple.com, 29.39% useboomerang.com, 27.76% Not measured
Fintech airwallex.com, 40.61% solidgate.com, 23.02% paymentsandrisk.com, 22.62% chargeflow.io, 14.06% stripe.com, 22.96% wise.com, 20.62% linkedin.com, 10.62%
Healthcare Services omnimd.com, 30.65% elevatepfs.com / phreesia.com, 12.45% nih.gov, 22.75% youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication), 10.88% omnimd.com, 24.36% medicalbillersandcoders.com, 17.32% nih.gov, 26.66%
HR & Talent pin.com, 25.00% lever.co, 12.89% performyard.com, 13.55% linkedin.com, 17.41% workforce.com, 31.33% rippling.com, 18.75% unleash.ai, 11.82%
iGaming & Betting tigsportsbook.com, 19.33% track360.io, 19.72% track360.io, 30.45% deucescracked.com, 13.64% geocomply.com, 23.77% track360.io, 23.28% Not measured
Industrial iqsdirectory.com, 12.71% industrialmonitordirect.com / reliamag.com, 7.39% americancleanrooms.com, 21.55% fabrico.io, 14.49% standardbots.com, 17.68% stamtec.com, 23.76% Not measured
Legacy News Topics Not measured Not measured Not measured Not measured Not measured Not measured linkedin.com, 10.21%
Local Services seattlesimplyclean.com, 19.31% thumbtack.com, 12.94% thumbtack.com, 15.35% angi.com, 9.72% thumbtack.com, 20.97% plumbinatoraustin.com, 17.56% Not measured
Logistics & Freight mycarrier.io, 14.84% freightwaves.com, 17.58% wearewarp.com, 18.78% dashdoc.com, 14.45% deposco.com, 18.68% chrobinson.com, 35.11% Not measured
Martech & Advertising bloomreach.com, 14.65% cdp.com, 26.97% cdp.com, 33.88% cometly.com, 12.02% g2.com, 19.86% cdp.com, 27.40% martech.org, 15.74%
Physical Consumer Products tomsguide.com, 23.68% rtings.com, 12.50% tomsguide.com, 17.88% youtube.com (only pages not mapped to a channel or publication), 16.94% consumerreports.org, 19.20% mattressnerd.com, 23.81% Not measured
Professional Services stonehillinnovation.com, 31.58% linkedin.com, 9.77% linkedin.com, 7.46% umbrex.com, 7.91% kore1.com / peoplemanagingpeople.com, 15.71% soc2auditors.org, 14.29% Not measured
Sales, GTM & CRM avoma.com, 21.38% hubspot.com, 24.48% sybill.ai, 14.75% avoma.com, 11.38% avoma.com, 14.75% hubspot.com, 19.66% Not measured
VC & Private Equity coyotewealth.com, 27.50% fundcount.com, 16.13% ctacquisitions.com, 11.11% v7labs.com, 12.50% carta.com, 31.46% carta.com, 16.48% Not measured

Do the cited sources support the answer? #

Answer-Source Fidelity is a separate measurement of claim support, not citation frequency. This edition preserves the published Fidelity snapshot generated 2026-11-15T11:36:43.444Z; it is not a week-only rate and may cover a different observation period from the Index.

Legacy baseline — frozen corpus, grade-time fetch basis #

Semantic cohort: c74383df31771cfe. Cohorts with different measurement semantics are not pooled.

  • ChatGPT (reported): Of the 1,255 resolvable citations for this engine, 54.8% were Supported; resolvable coverage was 77% (1,255/1,630).
  • Claude (collecting): Engine still COLLECTING: only 88 of 1,361 citations were resolvable (coverage 6.5%) — below the evidence floor, so no fidelity rate is reported.
  • Gemini (collecting): Engine still COLLECTING: only 392 of 4,349 citations were resolvable (coverage 9%) — below the evidence floor, so no fidelity rate is reported.
  • Perplexity (reported): Of the 1,298 resolvable citations for this engine, 50.1% were Supported; resolvable coverage was 47.6% (1,298/2,726).

Collection-time series — snapshot basis, bounded snapshot retry + deferral (F4-3) #

Semantic cohort: 06ddb22c15fa05d0. Cohorts with different measurement semantics are not pooled.

  • ChatGPT (reported): Of the 12,128 resolvable citations for this engine, 53.2% were Supported; resolvable coverage was 76.6% (12,128/15,837).
  • Claude (collecting): Engine still COLLECTING: only 0 of 0 citations were resolvable (coverage 0%) — below the evidence floor, so no fidelity rate is reported.
  • Gemini (collecting): Engine still COLLECTING: only 0 of 0 citations were resolvable (coverage 0%) — below the evidence floor, so no fidelity rate is reported.
  • Perplexity (collecting): Engine still COLLECTING: only 0 of 0 citations were resolvable (coverage 0%) — below the evidence floor, so no fidelity rate is reported.

Collection-time series — snapshot basis, bounded snapshot retry + deferral (F4-3), 12.5% random sample of every engine's citations #

Semantic cohort: 36357120b9cc2a56. Cohorts with different measurement semantics are not pooled.

  • ChatGPT (reported): Of the 1,398 resolvable citations in a 12.5% random sample of this engine's citations, 53.6% were Supported (±2.4 pts, 95%); resolvable coverage was 81.8% (1,398/1,710 sampled, ±1.7 pts).
  • Claude (collecting): Still COLLECTING: only 101 of 1,675 citations in a 12.5% random sample of this engine's citations were resolvable (coverage 6% ±1.1 pts) — below the evidence floor, so no fidelity rate is reported.
  • Gemini (collecting): Still COLLECTING: only 50 of 268 citations in a 12.5% random sample of this engine's citations were resolvable (coverage 18.7% ±4.4 pts) — below the evidence floor, so no fidelity rate is reported.
  • Perplexity (reported): Of the 1,739 resolvable citations in a 12.5% random sample of this engine's citations, 54.6% were Supported (±2.2 pts, 95%); resolvable coverage was 46.3% (1,739/3,759 sampled, ±1.5 pts).

Published dataset SHA-256: 894f442bb8488eb0cb8c85a7455dd938678e738fdfe7c5874efd63cd1e0157ac. Current measurement and method · Current dataset. The linked dataset advances; the snapshot above stays fixed with this edition.

How this report is built #

  • Source: the November 16, 2026 Machine Relations Index release (methodology v2.1, window 2026-05-10 to 2026-11-16), compared with the November 9, 2026 Machine Relations Index release. The current release is public at machinerelations.ai/data/machine-relations-index.json; figures for the earlier release are read from the same file as committed on 2026-11-09.
  • Rates are cumulative over the observation window, not rates for the week alone. Week-over-week change compares two published rates and is never read as a cause.
  • Only segments the release publishes, at 10 or more observed runs across 7 or more run dates, are reported. Only domains with a confidence tier (A, B or C) are ranked or listed as movers; tiers are the Index's own.
  • Domains operated by the publisher of this site or its related parties (authoritytech.io, machinerelations.ai, jaxonparrott.com, christianlehman.com, presspool.ai, paralabs.ai, paralax.ai) are left out of every ranking in this report. Their Index profiles remain public.
  • The method is the Index method, the open standard for measuring Machine Relations. Known data issues and corrections are logged in the Index update log. Corrections to an edition are made there and in the edition.

FAQ #

What is the Machine Relations Index Report? A weekly reading of the daily public release of the Machine Relations Index: the most-cited sources, the largest movers among graded domains and the leader of every published segment, each figure tied to a release id and linked to the Index page that publishes it.

Does a first place mean a source is better? No. It means answer engines cited it most often for that question shape in that category during the window. The Index measures citation, not accuracy; whether a cited source supports the answer is a separate measurement.

Why can a rate fall while a source gains citations? A rate is citations over observed runs. reddit.com was cited in 2,712 runs across its observation window against 2,668 in the window a week earlier, while observed runs grew to 40,194; the rate moves with both.

Cite this edition #

Machine Relations Index, Jaxon Parrott — machinerelations.ai. ChatGPT cites editorial publications 2.5 times as often as Google AI Overviews. The November 16, 2026 Machine Relations Index release. CC BY 4.0. https://machinerelations.ai/research/machine-relations-index-report-2026-11-16

APA

Parrott, J. (2026). Machine Relations Index Report, November 16, 2026: ChatGPT cites editorial publications 2.5 times as often as Google AI Overviews (November 16, 2026 release) [Data set]. Machine Relations Research. https://machinerelations.ai/research/machine-relations-index-report-2026-11-16

BibTeX

@misc{parrott2026mrimachinerelationsindexreport20261116,
  author = {Parrott, Jaxon},
  title = {Machine Relations Index Report, November 16, 2026: ChatGPT cites editorial publications 2.5 times as often as Google AI Overviews},
  year = {2026},
  version = {mri\_score\_v2.1+2026-11-16+a318eec2ae65},
  publisher = {Machine Relations Research},
  url = {https://machinerelations.ai/research/machine-relations-index-report-2026-11-16},
  license = {CC-BY-4.0},
  note = {Machine Relations Index, Jaxon Parrott — machinerelations.ai}
}

Citation file: https://machinerelations.ai/CITATION.cff